Canon S5 IS - the Canon Powershot S series is still my favorite

James and I originally set out on Saturday to both buy a Canon S5 IS at Future Shop, but they were out and gave us rain checks. Here's a link to Flickr's page about the S5 IS -- there are some amazing photos there.

More product shots

I've been a long time fan of the S series. I bought the S1 IS three years ago, and have been raving about it ever since: big zoom, great movie mode, really good optics, regular rechargeable AA batteries. I've taken most of the 7000 pictures on my Flickr account with the S1 IS. But, I recently dropped the camera and it's been acting up.

Sunset Basil

Luckily, Canon has continued to evolve the series. I've continued to recommend the series, and pretty much everyone I know that has bought one has been happy with it. About the *only* downside is its size: it's too big to be a pocket cam. But, I've always been happy with this trade off -- increasingly, my cellphone has been taking the role of pocket cam, and if I am going somewhere where I want really great pictures, I'll take the camera along.

Eating at Banana Leaf with Dad

So I ended up going to London Drugs this evening and bought the Canon S5 IS ... it's on for $499 there, but they'll price match Future Shop at $479. I went to the store on West Broadway -- Harry C was behind the counter and super knowledgeable. A 4GB SD card for $69 completed the purchase (and I just remembered that I forgot to get a UV filter -- recommended even just as a way to keep your main lens from scratching). First photo at right. Not super exciting, I know, but 8MP rather than the 3.2MP that I've been used to, and *excellent* low light performance.

In short, I still love the Canon PowerShot S series, and continue to recommend it to anyone that doesn't want a pocket cam.

You should buy this camera if you want:

  • a really big zoom (technically the ultrazoom category) -- the S5 is 12x optical
  • great macro modes -- the S5 actually has a 0cm "super macro" -- yes, you can actually put the lens directly on the thing you want to take a picture of (check out these macro shots of lemons on Flickr that were taken with the S5)
  • regular AA batteries -- esp. important when travelling
  • excellent movie quality, including sound -- 640x480 at 30fps, with stereo audio recording; oh yeah, and it actually has built in audio levels and even a wind filter
  • a rotating LCD screen -- from self portraits to crowd shots, I've been addicted
  • a viewfinder -- I actually take most of my pics through the viewfinder, which also saves batteries; the viewfinder just gives me more of a, well, professional feel, I guess
  • consistently good pictures -- there's not much fiddling to be done here, although you do have access to a lot of programmability

You should not buy this camera if you want:

  • something that fits in your pocket -- this is way smaller than an SLR, but it's not jean pocket sized
  • RAW support -- well, this really is high end camera stuff
  • an SLR -- while this is perfect for me, who just isn't going to add high end photography and lenses etc. etc. to stuff that I do, this is not a Digital SLR; it just happens to be a very good "prosumer" digital camera

Comments

RAW support for S5IS

Hello,

You may be interested in CHDK to give your S5IS RAW support...any comments?

http://chdk.wikia.com/wiki/CHDK_in_Brief

Got it working

I actually got this working: http://bmannconsulting.com/blog/bmann/getting-chdk-working-canon-s5-mac-...

However, the RAW files aren't reliably read by anything on Mac OS X. There is one app in alpha, but I gave up on RAW until the files are supported natively by OS X in some way.

but they only last 18 months

Here's how you can add RAW support to S2IS and S3IS

BUT

My S2IS is only 18 months old and the CCD is toast.

Canon refuses to fix the problem. I'm not the only one with this problem.

I loved the camera, but I won't be buying Canon again.

Oooh...RAW support

That's very cool. Will have to see if that works for the S5...

Re: 18 months: My S1IS lasted for 3 years, and then I dropped it. It still takes great pictures. I think they went more of a plastic body with the S2/S3...the S5 seems more solid once again (e.g. metal tripod mount, heavier than the last two).

Canon... Grrrr....

I bought Meg a Canon A610 for Christmas in 2005. Just recently, on her way to the Salar de Uyuni in Bolivia, the camera's imager seems to have given up the ghost. So, 20 months after purchase, 8 months out of warranty, and a little over 2,000 pictures into it's life it is in need of repair or replacement. Now, I think it has been dropped from a small height twice, but that was a while back, but otherwise it has been well treated. Oddly enough, Canon does have a 'service advisory'   offering free repairs for some of their older model cameras with this problem, but alas nothing with the A610. Calls to Canon support just yield me the instructions to bring it into their service center in Montreal where they can quote me what it will cost to repair. In comparison, my Olympus camera I bought nearly 5 years ago has taken a massive beating, but still takes photos like it was brand new.

Anyway, after this, I'm not sure I'd buy another Canon product. Less than two years life is ridiculous for something like this, you get more life from an iPod.

My Canon A610 died recently too

My Canon A610 died recently too. I can view existing images, but can't take nay more photos. Cant view from display. If I take photos from view finder anyway, the image is just pitch black.

It's been used for about two years. That's it, gone.

S Series

I really like my S2 IS, but there are a couple things I'd want to improve the product:

- a Li-Ion battery pack. Rechargeable AA batteries are a constant hassle

- Better image stabilization on long shots. Even with controlled breathing, the stabilization on the long shots

- A more intuitive mode knob. That knob is confusing. Some of the icons are pictures, others are letters. I'd prefer if it just used small type instead of single letters or confusing icons. When I want macro mode, I don't want to have to look up the manual, which is what I have to do now.

- A tutorial of examples on the computer so we can learn the more advanced features and get the most out of the UI

- A more intuitive UI. iPod's columns UI would be awesome.

- Slimmer. I assume current models are slimmer and lighter, so this may already be good.

No Li-Ion!

I probably wouldn't buy it if it had Li-Ion batteries. They would be a) more expensive and b) they don't last any longer than AA batteries.

If you've got old batteries (e.g. 2100 mAh), then it might be time to get some new rechargeables. I've always gotten *excellent* battery life out of mine. Note that I don't actually use the LCD other than reviewing pictures.

The mode knob is standardized across all Canon cameras, so if you've used others, it will seem very familiar. And M, Av, and Tv are actually across most digital cameras AFAIK. I don't think you could fit small descriptions...

On UI, etc. -- I think all digital cameras could use with improvement.

kevin@haggaret.com's picture

agreed

I'm going to have to agree with Boris on this one.  I love the fact that my S2 IS uses standard AA batteries instead of a battery pack.  With a battery pack - you're pretty much required to buy a second one (normally big $$) so you can still use the camera while the first is charging, or at least that was my experience with my old digital elph.  Using AA means you can buy them pretty much anywhere in an emergency or else just have a few sets of rechareables - which are also good for things like your wireless keyboard/mouse, GPS receiver, etc. With respect to battery life, again, like Boris, I haven't noticed a problem with battery life on my S2 IS.  I'm using Panasonic 2300 mAh rechargeables with it I believe and the batteries are a couple of years old.

I'll definitely keep an eye on the S series when I'm in the market for a new camera.  I've always been happy with my canon cameras to date and hopefully I'll continue to be as time goes on.

Li-ion don't last as long as rechargeable?

Li-Ion batteries don't last as long as rechargeable? All the articles I've read about portable power always list it as the battery with the biggest charge per volume. I'd be really surprised if that wasn't true. I do use 2500 mAh rechargeables, but I also put in Li-Ion non-rechargeable AA batteries and they lased a long, long time. Much longer than the rechargeables.

The mode knob may be standard, but that's not to say that it could use some improvement, that's for sure. If the knob is fine, then at least put the name of each setting on the viewfinder screen.

I went by a Futureshop tonight and checked out the Canon G7 and the S5 IS. It's a 10 mp camera with 6x optical zoom, and a Li-Ion battery pack, so I think the next purchase will be the G9, the G7's replacement, with 12mp, 6x optical zoom, a bigger viewscreen, a Li-Ion pack, and it's quite a bit more compact.

If I do upgrade, I'll donate the rechargeables if you want them. :)